Baked Sunday Mornings: Cherry Almond Crisp

I was initially excited for this week’s Baked Sunday Morning challenge, cherry almond crisp. I tend to be a fan of baked fruit desserts, and am suffering from a bout of insomnia, which oddly cherries may be able to help (there are some dubious results from a study of seven patients online). While I think this is a fitting dessert to celebrate President’s Day, as there is the famous story about Washington cutting down his father’s cherry tree, I really questioned the seasonality of this dessert. The recipe makes it seem like fresh cherries are required, but they are pretty impossible to find in February. Directions for using frozen cherries are located on the page before the recipe begins, on the narrative page, which in my sleep-deprived state I completely missed even though, yes it is in bold type. After thinking about it, I thought about sitting this one out until fresh cherries were available. A crisp showcases the fruit, and I wasn’t into using frozen fruit. I even went so far to make the orange almond ricotta cheesecake from Baked Elements for my going rouge entry. Then my husband came back with a giant bag of frozen cherries from Cosco, so I really had no excuse.


The really unique part of this recipe is the inclusion of cereal in the crisp topping. I used Cocoa Puffs, as chocolate is always a plus. Even though I came into Baked Sunday Mornings thinking I would never change a recipe, I really wanted to try them in their true form, I only added half of the almond extract (1 & 1/2 tsp) as a full tablespoon seemed really intense. I am glad I cut back on the almond extract as the finished product tasted like almonds without being overwhelming. I also noticed one of my fellow BSM bakers said they added 1/4 cup of sugar to the cherries and I too thought only 2 teaspoons of sugar was skimpy. However, I stuck to the 2 teaspoons and it was tart yet sweet. Just the way I like it. My husband thought it needed more crisp, the ratio of topping to fruit for him was a little off. I thought this was ok, but a disappointment compared with the to the pear plumb crisp from Frontiers which is my usual go to recipe. I really want to try this using fresh fruit during cherry season to see how it compares to frozen.

Check out what my fellow bakers thought here.

Recipe from Baked Occasions by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito


3 thoughts on “Baked Sunday Mornings: Cherry Almond Crisp

  1. Sheri says:

    Totally agree! And while I’m a fan of almond, I thought there was too much almond extract (one of the recipe testers thought the same… it’s interesting to see the final published recipe after it’s tested).

    I also figured I’d make this now, and then again in the summer with fresh cherries, to see if I like it more then.


  2. susanelester says:

    We really liked this – I’m glad the original recipe worked for you but sorry it wasn’t a favorite.


  3. Ditto both of you! This will be great with beautiful summer cherries. I made it with both fresh (gross) and frozen cherries, and it has potential, but it needs a couple of tweaks. I find almond extract disgusting, so I completely subbed vanilla, and the flavor was great. 🙂 How did you like the ricotta cheesecake?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: